Learning About Criminal Law from an Ontario Court Justice

1/31/2018

Erin Taylor, Communications Officer

The Grade 12 Law class recently began their unit on criminal law. What could be a better introduction to this unit than a presentation from an Ontario Court Justice?

The Honourable Paul Monahan currently sits in the Court of Justice in Brampton, where he hears criminal law proceedings. He came to Greenwood’s Grade 12 law class on January 19 and spoke to students about his extensive career in the Canadian justice system.

He talked candidly about the difficulties that arise when the theory of laws are applied in reality. The human element—such as the possible fallibility of witnesses, police, prosecutors, and judges—can potentially get in the way of a just ruling. He drew examples from the David Milgaard case, where inaccurate witnesses statements led to Milgaard’s wrongful conviction for murder, as well as examples from cases he has heard in court. Justice Monahan’s personal perspective gave students unique insights into the world of criminal justice.

Through these examples, he led students to an important lesson: in criminal law, it is essential to remain open-minded. Pre-judgments can prevent people from finding out the truth about complicated situations. Justice Monahan emphasized that those in the justice system must seek reasoned conclusions based on fact and evidence, rather than on assumptions and innuendo.

Through Justice Monahan’s presentation, students gained a more realistic perspective of the justice system. They have a better idea of some of its potential imperfections, but also how these can be managed and overcome.

Back

Justice Paul Monahan used the David Milgaard case as an example of how fallible witnesses can disrupt a just ruling

1/1

Greenwood College School

443 Mount Pleasant Road
Toronto, ON M4S 2L8
Tel: 416 482 9811

We acknowledge with gratitude the Ancestral lands upon which our main campus is situated. These lands are the Ancestral territories of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy, Mississaugas of the Credit First Nation, Anishinabek and the Wendake. The shared responsibility of this land is honoured in the Dish with One Spoon Treaty and we strive to care for the land, the waters, and all creatures in the spirit of peace. We are responsible for respecting and supporting the enduring presence of all First Nations, Métis and Inuit peoples. When away from this campus we vow to be respectful to the land by protecting and honouring it. We will create relationships with the people and the land we may visit by understanding the territories we enter and the nations who inhabit them.